Intel Unveils 6 nm Gate Length Silicon RibbonFET CMOS and Breakthroughs in Semiconductor Scaling at IEDM 2024

Intel Corporation / Intel Foundry has demonstrated and extensively characterized gate-all-around Silicon RibbonFET CMOS transistors with a 6 nm gate length (LG). The study showcases nanoribbon silicon thickness (Tsi) scaling down to 3 nm, enhancing short-channel effects without compromising performance. Effective workfunction engineering mitigates threshold voltage increases caused by quantum confinement at scaled Tsi, enabling reduced threshold voltage at highly scaled gate lengths. Injection velocity of 1.13x10^7 cm/s is maintained at LG=6nm without degradation down to Tsi=3 nm, highlighting advancements crucial for continued gate length scaling and the ongoing realization of Moore's Law.

Intel Foundry made groundbreaking announcements at the IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM) 2024, showcasing advancements that propel semiconductor technology into the next decade and beyond. Highlights include innovations in transistor and interconnect scaling, advanced packaging, and emerging materials to support the industry’s roadmap toward achieving 1 trillion transistors on a chip by 2030. Intel demonstrated a 25% capacitance reduction using subtractive ruthenium for interconnections, achieved a 100x throughput improvement in advanced packaging through Selective Layer Transfer (SLT), and advanced gate-all-around (GAA) transistor scaling with Silicon RibbonFET CMOS at a 6 nm gate length. Additionally, Intel unveiled new work on gate oxide modules for scaled 2D FETs, addressing the next phase of GAA scaling.

Among the key technical breakthroughs, subtractive ruthenium stands out as a metallization alternative to copper for interconnects, offering significant capacitance reductions at tight pitches while being cost-effective and scalable for high-volume manufacturing. SLT further revolutionizes advanced packaging with ultra-fast, flexible chip-to-chip assembly, enabling smaller, higher-density chiplets for AI and other demanding applications. For transistor scaling, Intel’s demonstration of Silicon RibbonFET CMOS at 6 nm gate length delivers industry-leading short-channel effects and performance, paving the way for continued scaling under Moore’s Law. Additionally, Intel’s progress with 2D GAA NMOS and PMOS transistors and gate oxide development signals readiness for post-silicon semiconductor technologies.

Intel also highlighted progress in gallium nitride (GaN) technology, demonstrating the first 300 mm GaN-on-TRSOI substrates for high-performance power and RF electronics. These developments, alongside Intel’s continued focus on advanced memory integration, hybrid bonding, and modular system expansion, underscore its commitment to addressing challenges in AI, energy efficiency, and thermal management. With these innovations, Intel Foundry continues to lead the charge in semiconductor advancements, ensuring a robust path forward for the trillion-transistor era.

Source: Intel IEDM 2024 Innovations

Boosting the Future: Increased ALD Use Paves the Way for Advanced GAAFET Technology

The Biden administration is considering a complete ban on the export of chips utilizing Gate All-Around Field Effect Transistor (GAAFET) technology to China, Bloomberg reports (LINK). The rationale behind this potential ban is the concern that such advanced transistors could be leveraged for military applications and artificial intelligence (AI) advancements by China. This move follows previous restrictions from 2022, when the U.S. barred its Electronic Design and Automation (EDA) companies from selling tools necessary for GAAFET development to China. In addition, advanced chip exports from companies like Nvidia were restricted, with these measures being progressively tightened and expanded over time.

Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) is celebrating its 50th anniversary in 2024. The anniversary marks 50 years since Dr. Tuomo Suntola and his colleagues filed the first patent for Atomic Layer Epitaxy in 1974, which laid the foundation for ALD technology. This milestone will be celebrated at various events, including the ALD 2024 conference, where Dr. Suntola is expected to deliver the opening remarks .

ASM International, a leader in Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD), plays a crucial role in enabling Gate-All-Around Field Effect Transistors (GAAFETs) and continued semiconductor scaling. ALD's precision in depositing ultra-thin, uniform films is essential for creating the high-performance, low-power structures required by GAAFETs. This technology, along with other advanced processes such as epitaxy and selective etching, supports the intricate fabrication steps needed for these next-generation transistors.

The production of GAAFETs requires a significant increase in the use of ALD technology - maybe up to 40% more according to ASM. ALD is essential for creating the ultra-thin, uniform films needed for GAAFET structures, ensuring high-quality, defect-free layers that are critical for advanced transistor performance. This technology enables precise control over the deposition process, crucial for developing high-k dielectrics and other materials that enhance GAAFET performance and efficiency. As the semiconductor industry now transitions from FinFET to GAAFET technology, leveraging ALD's capabilities is vital for maintaining and advancing Moore's Law, enabling more powerful and energy-efficient chips using existing manufacturing infrastructure

Applied Materials has outlined next-generation tools essential for producing 3nm and GAA transistors, such as those in Samsung's upcoming 3GAE and 3GAP technologies. These advanced tools address the complexities of GAA transistor manufacturing, including precise lithography, epitaxy, and selective materials removal. Applied's Producer Selectra Selective Etch IMS tool is pivotal in defining channel width without damaging surrounding materials, while the Centura Prime Epi tool ensures clean deposition of Si and SiGe nanosheets. Additionally, their Integrated Materials Solution (IMS) systems integrate atomic layer deposition (ALD), thermal steps, and plasma treatments to optimize the gate oxide stack, enhancing performance and reducing gate leakage. These innovations are crucial as they enable higher performance, lower power consumption, and greater transistor density, aligning with the industry's move from FinFET to GAA technology.

Today GAA transistors are currently in mass production only by Samsung, which offered the technology to customers with its 3-nanometer process in 2022. Intel is set to follow, producing GAAFET on its 2-nanometer process expected to be available in its products later this year. TSMC, the market leader, plans to introduce GAAFET with its own 2 nm process in 2025. The GAAFET technology itself is not inherently suited for AI or military applications but represents an evolution in transistor design, enabling denser packing of transistors as lithography equipment and manufacturing processes advance. This technology shift, akin to transitioning to a new node, typically results in either reduced power consumption or improved performance by 15-25%.

The improvements facilitated by GAAFET could significantly enhance the capabilities available to China. SMIC, China's largest contract manufacturer, currently produces chips on a 7 nm process and is believed to be capable of reaching at least 5 nanometers with existing tools. The combination of this process with GAAFET could theoretically prevent China from falling too far behind Western advancements. However, China has been effectively shut out from developing GAAFET using tools from leading EDA companies, all of which are American. Additionally, the Dutch company ASML, dominant in the lithography equipment market, has not sold its EUV (Extreme Ultraviolet) machines to China and faced further restrictions in 2023 on selling its advanced DUV (Deep Ultraviolet) equipment. In April 2024, ASML took another step in the tech war against China by announcing that it would no longer service existing equipment in China, potentially crippling the country's semiconductor manufacturing capabilities. The specific details of the new export bans are still unclear, but Reuters notes that initial proposals have faced criticism from the U.S. semiconductor industry for being overly broad and extensive.

Source: USA överväger ytterligare GAAFET-sanktioner mot Kina – Semi14, www.ASM.com, Applied Materials Outlines Next-Gen Tools for 3nm and GAA Transistor Era (anandtech.com), Atomic layer deposition, next-gen transistors, and ASM (techfund.one)

The Semiconductor Showdown: TSMC's GAA FETs vs. Intel's RibbonFET

The semiconductor industry is witnessing a fierce competition between TSMC and Intel, as they advance transistor designs with TSMC's Gate-All-Around (GAA) FETs and Intel's RibbonFET. Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) plays an instrumental role in crafting these intricate designs. As the race to dominate the microelectronics realm heats up, the innovations from these giants foretell a transformative phase for technology between 2024 and 2026. This article dives into their respective technologies, comparing their strategies and highlighting the future implications for the semiconductor industry.

Both TSMC and Intel are pushing the boundaries of semiconductor innovation with advanced transistor designs. TSMC's GAA (Gate-All-Around) FET (Field-Effect Transistor) technology and Intel's RibbonFET are prime examples of this evolution. ALD is crucial for GAA FET production, ensuring precision and atomically thin, conformal or on purpose non-conformal or selectively deposited films. As transistors miniaturized, ALD replaced traditional silicon dioxide gate dielectrics with high-k materials, reducing gate leakage and offering enhanced uniformity. One of the challenges in GAA FETs is accurately aligning the gate material around the channel; ALD facilitates this through self-aligned processes. Additionally, in configurations with multiple gates or nanosheets, ALD accurately deposits spacer materials, preserving the necessary separation between nanosheets. ALD also offers precise doping for GAA FETs, including NMOS and PMOS. With atomic-level control, ALD introduces dopants like phosphorus for NMOS and boron for PMOS. Given the shrinking device dimensions, ALD's precision becomes vital, especially when considering techniques like solid-state doping to achieve ultra-shallow profiles.

TSMC's Gate-All-Around (GAA) FET technology represents a significant shift from the traditional FinFET transistor design. In a GAA FET, the gate material wraps entirely around the channel, unlike the FinFET where the gate is only on three sides of a vertical fin. This complete encirclement provides enhanced control over the current flow through the channel, reducing leakage current and allowing for lower voltage operation. The result is improved energy efficiency and performance.

TSMC's roadmap to N2. (Image: TSMC)

On the other hand, Intel's RibbonFET introduces a similar gate-all-around design but with a unique twist. Instead of a traditional vertical fin, RibbonFET uses nanosheet technology, where multiple flat nano-sheets are stacked to form the channel. This design offers even better control of the current flow, leading to significant gains in performance and efficiency. RibbonFET is one of Intel's flagship innovations for its advanced nodes, emphasizing the company's commitment to reclaiming technology leadership in the semiconductor space.

Intel 20A Ribbon FET (intel.com)

In a recent article Tom´s Hardware (Anton Shilow, link below) compares the advanced semiconductor technology nodes from industry TSMC and Intel, focusing on TSMC's N3P and N2 nodes against Intel's 20A and 18A nodes. Forecasted for release between 2024 and 2026, these nodes represent the forefront of semiconductor innovation. TSMC's N3P, a 3nm-class node, is set to be available by 2025 and offers performance comparable to Intel's 18A. Interestingly, TSMC's 2nm-class N2, expected in the second half of 2025, is anticipated to outpace Intel's 18A in terms of power, performance, and area advantages. Intel's 20A, arriving in 2024, promises significant advancements by introducing RibbonFET gate-all-around transistors and a backside power delivery network. The subsequent 18A will further refine these innovations. While TSMC leans on its proven FinFET technology for the N3P, it plans to introduce nanosheet GAA transistors in the N2. 

As the semiconductor race intensifies, both companies are heavily invested in outpacing each other, with TSMC focusing on technology maturity and cost-effectiveness, and Intel aiming to regain its technology leadership. The dynamics between these tech giants will shape the semiconductor industry's future.

Comparison of Advanced Semiconductor Technology Nodes: TSMC N3P & N2 vs. Intel 20A & 18A, highlighting the competitive landscape of the semiconductor industry for the years 2024-2026 based on Toms Hardware article below.

Sources: 

TSMC: Our 3nm Node Comparable to Intel's 1.8nm Tech | Tom's Hardware (tomshardware.com)

Intel and TSMC company web pages

Applied Materials to present New Innovations Needed to Continue Scaling Advanced Logic (June 16)

Applied Materials (Santa Clara, USA): The semiconductor industry is at a crossroads. Demand for chips has never been greater as we enter the early stages of a new wave of growth fueled by the Internet of Things, Big Data and AI. At the same time, it’s become apparent that conventional Moore’s Law 2D scaling techniques are no longer able to deliver the consistent improvements in power, performance, area-cost and time to market (PPACt) that chipmakers have long relied on. This is particularly the case for logic chips, which serve as the main processing engine in nearly every electronic product and where power efficiency and performance are critical.

To shed light on this issue, Applied Materials is hosting an online Logic Master Class on Wednesday, June 16. I will be joined by other experts from Applied and the industry to discuss the logic scaling roadmap, including challenges and solutions for delivering continued improvements in PPACt. We will be exploring several different areas, including transistor and interconnect scaling, patterning and design technology co-optimization (DTCO). The common denominator underlying all of these areas is the need to supplement classic 2D scaling with a combination of approaches that includes new chip architectures, new 3D structures, novel materials, new ways to shrink features and new ways to connect chips with advanced packaging.

Source: Applied Materials Blog (LINK)

Primary modules of a FinFET are channel and shallow trench isolation (1), high-k metal gate (2) and transistor source/drain resistance (3). (Credit: Applied Materials)

Intel to present 3D stacked Nanoribbon Transistors for Continued Moore’s Law Scaling at IEDM 2020

Intel to present stacked gate-all-around FET (GAA-FET) technology, i.e., a complementary FET (CFET) at IEDM2020. In CFETs, the idea is to stack both nFET and pFET wires on each other. A CFET could stack one nFET on top of a pFET wire, or two nFETs on top of two pFET wires. This ‘folding’ of the nFET and pFET eliminates the n-to-p separation bottleneck, reducing the cell active area footprint (LINK). Please find the announcement below:

Home-2020 - IEDM 2020 ieee-iedm.org IEDM Conference 2020. To Be Held Virtually December 12-18. The on demand portion of the conference will begin on December 5th. Intel to present 3D stacked Nanoribbon Transistors for Continued Moore’s Law Scaling: 

Stacked NMOS-on-PMOS Nanoribbons: From planar MOSFETs, to FinFETs, to gate-all-around (GAA) or nanoribbon devices, novel transistor architectures have played a critical role in driving performance predicted by Moore’s Law. Intel researchers will describe what may be the next step in that evolution: NMOS-on-PMOS transistors built from multiple self-aligned stacked nanoribbons. This architecture employs a vertically stacked dual source/drain epitaxial process and a dual metal gate fabrication process, enabling different conductive types of nanoribbons to be built so that threshold voltage adjustments can be made for both top and bottom nanoribbons. The approach combines excellent electrostatics (subthreshold slope of <75 mV/dec) and DIBL (<30mV/V for gates ≥30nm) with a path to significant cell size reduction due to the self-aligned stacking. These devices were used to build a functional CMOS inverter with well-balanced voltage transfer characteristics. (Paper #20.6, “3-D Self-Aligned Stacked NMOS-on-PMOS Nanoribbon Transistors for Continued Moore’s Law Scaling,” C.-Y. Huang et al, Intel) 

Paper #20.6, “3-D Self-Aligned Stacked NMOS-on-PMOS Nanoribbon Transistors for Continued Moore's Law Scaling,” C.-Y. Huang et al, Intel

Paper Information (IEDM 2020) : LINK

Figures from IEDM 2020 Press briefing Material -Press kit : LINK

In the images above:

·        (1) shows the evolution of transistor architectures from planar, to FinFETs, to nanoribbons and to a 3D CMOS architecture.

·        (2) (a) shows a 3D schematic diagram of stacked CMOS Si nanoribbon transistors with NMOS on PMOS, (b) describes the process flow; (c) is a TEM image of a stacked multiple-nanoribbon CMOS inverter with a 40-nm gate length and inner (V_ss) and outer (V_cc) contacts, a common gate input (V_IN) and an inverter output node (V_OUT); while (d) is a TEM image of two Si NMOS nanoribbons atop 3 Si PMOS nanoribbons.

·       (3) (a) is a process flow of the vertically stacked dual S/D EPI process, while (b) shows P-EPI selectively grown on the bottom three nanoribbons, (c) shows N-EPI selectively grown on the top two nanoribbons, and (d) features TEM and EDS images showing selective N-EPI and P-EPI growth on the stacked nanoribbon transistors.

·       (4) (a) is a process flow of the vertically stacked dual metal gate process; (b) is a TEM image and (c, d) are EDS images of the dual metal gate with N-WFM (WFM = work function metal) on the top two nanoribbons and P-WFM on the bottom three nanoribbons.

Samsung's 3 nm Gate-All-Around FET prototype

Samsung has succeeded in making the first strides towards the 3 nm process, as reported by the Korean Maeil Economy this week. According to the report, Samsung's goal is to become the world's number one semiconductor manufacturer by 2030.

Samsung's work on the 3 nm process is based on the Gate All Around (GAAFET) technology rather than FinFET. This supposedly reduces the total silicon size by 35% while using about 50% less power and allows for the same amount of power consumption and 33% performance increase over the 5 nm FinFET process.

Gate-All-Around FETs - Picture credit: Samsung

Source: Toms Hardware (LINK)

----------

By AbhishekkumarThakur